10 reasons many divorces end in regret and second thoughts

Commentators like Scott Galloway have pointed out that women initiate 70% of divorces and that financial insecurity consistently sits near the center of those decisions.

Men frequently complain of hypergamy in reverse: that in some cases, they emerge financially or socially ahead after multiple divorces, while their former spouses shoulder both economic and emotional burdens. Women, meanwhile, often carry the heaviest load as custodial parents, investing daily labor in childcare and household management, while secondary parents retain freedom, autonomy, and social mobility.

Society and the courts compound this imbalance: tangible wealth, property, and income are quantifiable, while emotional contributions and caregiving remain largely invisible. The result is a deeply felt inequity in which both sides can feel wronged, but for very different reasons. It is in this tension among financial outcomes, emotional labor, and social expectations that regret, frustration, and second thoughts frequently emerge long before the divorce is finalized.

The Promise vs. Reality of Divorce

When couples decide to divorce, they often imagine the end of conflict, loneliness, or dissatisfaction. Yet what they frequently encounter instead is a complex reality where emotional relief coexists with new pressures and uncertainties. Many people underestimate how deeply intertwined their routines, identities, and social networks are with their spouse.

Once the marriage ends, those connections don’t simply disappear; they transform, sometimes shrinking rather than expanding. Surveys indicate that a large proportion of divorcees miss their ex‑partners, especially early in the post‑divorce period. This clash between expectation and lived experience is one of the early seeds of regret.

Custodial Parents

Primary caregiving after divorce falls heavily on mothers in many countries, and the United States is no exception. In the U.S., nearly 80% of custodial parents are mothers, while only about 20% are fathers, a figure that has held fairly steady over recent years in large national surveys.

In many custody decisions, whether formal or informally agreed upon, mothers assume the larger share of parenting time and decision‑making, which can intensify the pressure they face post‑divorce. For these women, the practical demands of school runs, doctor’s appointments, bedtime routines, and emotional care can quickly consume what little personal time remains.

Financial data also show that custodial mothers are much more likely to experience economic hardship after divorce, magnifying stress and limiting autonomy.  Rather than feeling liberated, many custodial parents find themselves squeezed by responsibility, which can lead to profound regret.

Secondary Parents

Non‑custodial or secondary parents often are fathers, but increasingly both genders enter post‑divorce life hoping for regained autonomy and personal time. But that freedom can quickly give way to guilt and a sense of missing important moments in their children’s lives.

Maintaining a bond with children across households requires intentional effort, and inconsistent contact can lead to emotional distance over time. Studies have documented shifts in parent–child time use following separation, with non‑residential parents often struggling to maintain involvement. This dynamic can create a paradox: the very autonomy one sought becomes tinged with regret over lost connection.

Loneliness exists even out of Marriage

One of the primary motivators for divorce is loneliness within a marriage. People tell themselves that walking away will cure the sense of disconnection they’ve felt for years. But loneliness is not simply a function of companionship; it’s a mental and emotional state that can persist or even worsen when structural support systems change.

Feelings of loneliness and isolation are among the top psychological sources of regret after divorce. Without the daily rhythm of shared life and support, individuals may find themselves confronting the same internal emptiness they hoped to escape, only now with fewer buffers.

Loss of Autonomy

Many assume that leaving a marriage will increase autonomy, that they’ll suddenly control their own time, decisions, and future. In reality, autonomy after divorce often becomes fragmented by the demands of co‑parenting, financial restructuring, and legal obligations. Parenting schedules, school calendars, and custody exchanges create a new set of routines that can feel as restrictive as the old ones.

Financial and legal constraints, from splitting assets to maintaining two households, further limit the autonomy people expected to gain. For many, this realization only crystallizes after the divorce is final, when they must navigate these constraints day by day.

Life Planning Prior to the Exit

Professionals who work with couples considering divorce often emphasize the need for comprehensive planning, social, financial, and psychological, before filing papers. Yet many people enter the process without a clear roadmap for life after separation. They underestimate how much of their social life, emotional support network, and even their work identity may be tied to their marriage.

As a result, the post‑divorce period can feel like being adrift rather than empowered. Those who plan ahead, building social supports, financial stability, and personal goals, tend to adjust better, while those who don’t report regret rooted in surprise and unpreparedness.

Litigation Fatigue

Litigation over custody, property, or support frequently drags on for months, sometimes even years, draining emotional, financial, and mental reserves. The repeated negotiations, court appearances, and adversarial communication with an ex create a cycle of stress that can make daily life feel like a battle rather than a fresh start.

This phenomenon, often called litigation fatigue, is one of the reasons many people begin to question whether the separation is worth the personal cost. In fact, a noticeable percentage of couples end up reconciling or pausing the divorce process because the prolonged emotional strain and financial burden become too heavy to bear.

The relentless nature of the legal proceedings can force couples to confront whether the marriage problems they thought were insurmountable might be addressed outside the courtroom.

The Dating Market Isn’t the Same One You Left

People who once navigated the dating world as young singles often assume they can return to a familiar landscape after divorce. But the social and romantic markets change over time: norms shift, platforms evolve, and people’s priorities shift with age.

Many divorced individuals find that dating feels less spontaneous and more transactional than they expected. Some struggle with insecurity or fear of repeating past patterns, while others confront the challenge of integrating their children’s needs into any new relationship. Research on post‑divorce social adjustment highlights how isolation and difficulty forming new attachments can persist long after the legal separation.

Children’s Emotional Realities and Regret

Divorce inevitably reshapes children’s lives, and for many parents, concerns about their children’s emotional adjustment become a core source of post‑divorce reflection or regret. Parental separation often disrupts routines, emotional security, and even children’s behavior or attachment styles.

Some children adapt well over time, but others experience anxiety or stress that parents find hard to witness. The fear that the decision to divorce might have cost children stability or emotional well‑being can be a profound and lingering source of regret for many parents.

Second Thoughts as a Phase of Grief

Feeling doubts after divorce does not automatically mean the decision was wrong; it often reflects the normal process of emotional disentanglement and loss. Psychological research identifies grief, identity redefinition, and attachment transitions as core parts of adjusting to life after divorce.

These emotional currents swirl together: loss of companionship, shifts in role, and reconfiguration of self‑identity. For many people, second thoughts diminish with time and adjustment; what feels like regret in the first year can later be seen as part of the healing arc. But without awareness of this emotional phase, the intensity of second thoughts can feel overwhelming and permanent.

Key Takeaways

• Divorce is often triggered less by lost love and more by financial instability and structural stress.
• Women initiate most divorces yet disproportionately absorb the long-term burden of custody and emotional labor.
• Men and women experience post-divorce “loss” differently, fueling competing narratives of injustice.
• Courts quantify income and assets but largely ignore emotional and caregiving contributions.
• Regret and second thoughts emerge from this mismatch between what is measured and what is actually lost.

Disclosure line: This article was written with the assistance of AI and was subsequently reviewed, revised, and approved by our editorial team.

Like our content? Be sure to follow us