10 reasons you’re no different from the religious leaders who rejected Jesus

The most unsettling truth of faith is not that ancient leaders rejected Jesus, but that their mindset feels painfully at home in us.

It is easy to sit in a comfortable pew and criticize the Pharisees for missing the Messiah standing right in front of them, but we often mirror their exact behavior without realizing it. We convince ourselves that we would have welcomed Jesus with open arms, yet our daily actions suggest we might have been the first to call for his arrest. If we look closely at our modern religious habits, the uncomfortable truth is that we prioritize our traditions over the radical love that Jesus actually preached.

The religious elite of that day were not villains in their own eyes; they were devout believers who thought they were protecting God’s law from a dangerous radical. They felt justified in their rejection because Jesus threatened their status, their rules, and their understanding of how the world should work. Today, we risk falling into the same trap when we let our pride and rigid systems blind us to the simple, messy work of loving our neighbors.

You Obsess Over Public Image

Many of us treat our faith like a social media highlight reel, making sure everyone sees how “blessed” and righteous we look on the outside. We pray loud prayers and wear our morality like a badge of honor, hoping to gain respect from our peers rather than approval from God. It is a performance designed to hide our insecurities, mirroring the religious leaders who loved the best seats in the synagogue.

The danger is that we start believing our own press releases, thinking our public reputation equals spiritual maturity. We hide our struggles because we are terrified that admitting weakness will ruin the image we have worked so hard to build. Jesus warned against doing good deeds to be seen by others, yet we often measure our spiritual success by how many people notice our piety.

You Value Tradition More Than People

The Pharisees were famous for washing their hands and cups while ignoring the dirt in their hearts, and we often do the exact same thing with our church traditions. We get angry when the music style changes or someone wears jeans to the service, forgetting that Jesus cared about hearts, not rituals. An Arizona Christian University study found that 64% of evangelicals qualify as “Syncretists,” meaning they mix biblical beliefs with other worldly ideas, often prioritizing cultural habits over scripture.

We build fences around our faith to keep people out rather than building bridges to bring them in, just like the leaders who scolded Jesus for healing on the Sabbath. When we care more about the order of service than the person crying in the back row, we have missed the point entirely. Jesus constantly broke social norms to reach people, while we often use those same norms to keep “undesirable” people at a safe distance.

You Judge Others To Feel Superior

It feels good to look down on someone else’s sin because it distracts us from the mess in our own lives. We categorize sins, deciding that our gossip or greed is acceptable while someone else’s lifestyle is an abomination. According to Barna Group data, 51% of self-identified Christians in the U.S. are characterized by Pharisaical attitudes and actions, particularly self-righteousness, rather than the attitudes of Jesus.

This superiority complex is exactly why the religious leaders despised Jesus for eating with tax collectors and sinners. We create an “us versus them” mentality that makes us feel safe and holy, but it actually isolates us from the very people Jesus came to save. True faith should lead to humility, but for many of us, it just becomes a tool to boost our ego.

You Protect The Institution Above All

We often defend our church structures and denominations with more passion than we defend the gospel itself. When abuse or corruption comes to light, our first instinct is often to hush it up to “protect the witness” of the church. This is the same fear that drove the High Priest to say it was better for one man to die than for the whole nation to perish.

We cling to our buildings and budgets, terrified that losing them means losing God, which is a lie that keeps us paralyzed. We act as if God needs our organization to survive, forgetting that the church is a movement of people, not a corporation. Gallup reported in 2024 that only 32% of Americans express high confidence in the church, a sign that protecting the institution over truth has destroyed our credibility.

You Misinterpret Scripture To Suit Your Agenda

We love to cherry-pick verses that support our political views or personal biases while ignoring the ones that challenge us. We use the Bible as a weapon to attack our enemies rather than a mirror to examine our own souls. The religious leaders of Jesus’ time knew the scriptures better than anyone, yet they used them to justify murdering the Author of life.

It is convenient to quote verses about judgment when we want to condemn, but we skip the parts about mercy when we want revenge. We twist the words of God to back up our prejudices, making God look exactly like us. A 2025 report from Lifeway Research noted that Bible use was at about 41%, suggesting we are engaging less with the text and more with our own opinions.

You Ignore The Marginalized

Jesus spent his time with the outcasts, but we usually structure our lives to avoid them completely. We build comfortable bubbles where we never have to interact with the poor, the addicted, or the socially awkward. We say we love everyone, but our calendars and bank accounts show that we really only love people who can do something for us.

The religious elite saw the poor as cursed, while Jesus saw them as the inheritors of the kingdom. We might drop a few dollars in the offering plate, but we rarely get our hands dirty helping those in actual need. Ignoring the plight of the vulnerable is a hallmark of the religious spirit that Jesus despised more than anything else.

You Fear Change More Than Disobedience

We get comfortable with the way things are and view any disruption as a threat from the devil. When the Holy Spirit tries to move in a new way, we shut it down because it does not fit our schedule or our theology. The Pharisees rejected Jesus largely because he was doing something new that they could not control or predict.

We prefer a tame God who stays in the box we have built for him, rather than the wild God who flips tables. We choose the safety of the known over the risk of faith, calling it wisdom when it is actually fear. Pew Research found in 2025 that 58% of adults feel conflicted between their faith and mainstream culture, often retreating into fear rather than engaging with courage.

You Demand External Signs Of Piety

We judge people by how they dress, how they talk, or whether they have the right bumper stickers on their cars. We assume that if someone looks the part, they must be right with God, which is a dangerous assumption. Jesus called this being a “whitewashed tomb”—looking beautiful on the outside but being full of death on the inside.

We put pressure on new believers to conform to our cultural codes before we help them follow Jesus. We make the gospel about behavior modification instead of heart transformation. Baptist Press says Barna research shows that only 31% of teens view Christians as loving, while 18% explicitly view them as hypocritical, largely due to this focus on outward appearance.

You Are Politically Motivated

We often conflate the Kingdom of God with our preferred political party, assuming God votes exactly as we do. We compromise our values to gain political power, thinking we can legislate righteousness into people’s hearts. The religious leaders handed Jesus over to Rome because they were playing a political game to keep their power.

We spend more energy arguing about policies than we do spreading the good news of salvation. We have traded our birthright for a bowl of political stew, alienating half the people we are supposed to be reaching. When we wrap the cross in a flag, we dilute the power of the gospel and turn it into just another earthly agenda.

You Lack Genuine Empathy

We are quick to offer a theological explanation for someone’s pain instead of just sitting with them in their grief. We offer clichés like “everything happens for a reason” because we are uncomfortable with suffering. Jesus wept with those who wept, but we often rush to fix the problem so we can move on with our day.

Our hearts have grown hard because we care more about being right than being kind. We have lost the ability to feel the weight of another person’s burden. If we cannot feel the pain of others, we have lost the very heart of what it means to follow the suffering Servant.

Disclosure: This article was developed with the assistance of AI and was subsequently reviewed, revised, and approved by our editorial team.

Like our content? Be sure to follow us