12 states some retirees say they would avoid moving to again
Choosing where to retire is one of the biggest financial and lifestyle decisions Americans make later in life, and recent migration data shows just how much geography matters.
According to SmartAsset’s analysis of U.S. Census Bureau migration patterns, nearly 1 million adults aged 60 and older moved across state lines in 2023, with retirees increasingly relocating based on affordability, healthcare access, taxes, and quality-of-life factors rather than tradition or family ties alone.
At the same time, multiple retirement studies and surveys show a growing trend of “retirement regret moves,” where some retirees later say they would not choose the same state again due to cost pressures, climate challenges, healthcare access, or lifestyle mismatches.
While preferences vary widely from person to person, certain states are repeatedly mentioned in discussions about difficult retirement experiences, often due to high living costs, taxes, infrastructure issues, or expectations that don’t match reality.
Here are 12 states some retirees say they would avoid moving to again, and why.
Florida
Florida still has the classic retirement shine: no state income tax, warm winters, beaches, golf carts, large retiree communities, and enough sunshine to make a January morning feel like a fresh start. But the numbers explain why some retirees say they would think twice before moving there again.
The Census Bureau reported that Florida had the highest median annual property insurance cost for mortgaged homes in 2023 at $2,273, and Bankrate ranked Florida 41st in its 2025 retirement study, noting that it scored well on taxes and retiree population but poorly on health care, home insurance costs, and natural disasters.
GoBankingRates also estimated Florida’s comfortable retirement cost at $88,339 a year in 2026, which is far from bargain-basement living. The regret often comes from the gap between “no income tax” and the monthly reality of insurance, HOA dues, flood coverage, storm prep, roof repairs, and car-dependent living. Paradise can still be paradise, but it starts to feel different when the renewal notice arrives before hurricane season.
Texas
Texas can sound like the retirement deal of the decade: no state income tax, plenty of space, big cities, small towns, and housing that can still look reasonable compared with coastal markets. But some retirees later find that the state’s hidden costs walk in through other doors.
The Dallas Fed reported in 2026 that the median Texas homeowner paid 60% more for home insurance in 2024 than in 2019, while the national median rose 30% over that period. Bankrate ranked Texas 49th for retirement in 2025, and local reporting on the ranking noted weak scores for health care access, safety, similarly aged residents, affordability, and weather, despite a strong tax score.
Summer heat can also push air-conditioning bills into uncomfortable territory, especially for retirees on a fixed income. So the Texas regret story is not that the tax perk is fake. It is that taxes are only one bill in a stack. Once insurance, property taxes, utilities, hail risk, severe storms, and medical access are factored into the budget, the clean “no income tax” pitch can feel much messier.
Louisiana
Louisiana can look gentle on the wallet when you compare home prices, food culture, music, and community life with pricier coastal states. But retirees who move for affordability can be startled by the math storm.
The Census Bureau found that Louisiana had the second-highest median annual property insurance cost for mortgaged homes in 2023 at $2,140, just behind Florida. Bankrate ranked Louisiana last overall in its 2025 retirement study, citing weak scores in neighborhood safety, affordability, weather, and health care.
GoBankingRates, meanwhile, found that Louisiana was one of the states where a comfortable retirement could require a lower monthly savings target than many others, which shows the tradeoff clearly: everyday costs may look friendly, but disaster risk can make the budget feel unstable.
A low home price can feel like victory on moving day. Then flood maps, wind coverage, storm deductibles, evacuation plans, and premium hikes start writing their own chapter. For some retirees, cheap housing does not feel cheap once worry becomes part of the payment.
California
California can spoil a person with ocean air, mountains, fresh produce, good hospitals in major metros, and winter weather that makes snowbird life unnecessary. But the retirement bill can be fierce.
GoBankingRates reported in 2026 that a comfortable retirement in California costs about $146,773 a year, second only to Hawaii in its ranking. Bankrate also placed California among the 10 worst states for retirees in 2025, and McKinsey reported in 2025 that California’s private homeowners insurance market faces a coverage shortfall of $1.35 trillion to $2 trillion tied to wildfire risk, private insurance gaps, and FAIR Plan exposure.
McKinsey said restoring market balance could require $8 billion to $10 billion in additional annual premiums, at a time when homeowners already struggle with affordability. That is the California tension in one frame: the weather can feel soft, but the cost structure can be hard.
For retirees without large pensions, major assets, or family support, sunshine may not be enough to soften housing costs, taxes, insurance premiums, wildfire risk, and everyday prices.
Nevada
Nevada sells a clear retirement dream: no state income tax, relatively low property taxes, entertainment, desert views, and in some areas, easier access to California families without California prices. But the lived version can be hotter, drier, and costlier than the brochure suggests.
Kiplinger ranked Nevada among its tax-friendly states for retirees in 2026, noting that there is no state income tax, a median property tax bill of $1,937, and an average effective property tax rate of 0.49%. That is the appealing side. The harder side shows up in heat and utility pressure.
Nevada Current reported in 2025 that extreme heat takes a toll on Nevadans’ health and pocketbooks, and a separate report noted that NV Energy sought a $224 million rate hike. Long summers mean air conditioning is not a luxury; it is a matter of survival.
For some retirees, the state’s tax math stays attractive, but the day-to-day life of high heat, water worries, HOA fees, car dependence, and rising power bills feels heavier than expected. A low-tax home can still become expensive when the thermostat never gets a vacation.
New Jersey
New Jersey has real retirement strengths: proximity to family, access to major medical systems, beaches, transit into New York and Philadelphia, and established communities. But the cost pressure can feel relentless on a fixed income.
CareScout ranked New Jersey as the worst state to retire in for 2026, citing the high cost of living, a top personal income tax rate of 10.75%, and poor aging and health indicators, despite the state having the highest average Social Security income at $29,562. GoBankingRates estimated that a comfortable retirement in New Jersey costs $115,405 annually in 2026, placing it among the 13 states above $100,000.
That means even retirees who moved back for grandchildren or lifelong roots may find themselves squeezed by property taxes, housing, insurance, groceries, and care costs. New Jersey can be deeply worthwhile for family and access, but regret can creep in when every convenience comes with a bill. The emotional math may say “stay close.” The household budget may say, “can we keep doing this?”
New York
New York can be a gift in older age if you value transit, culture, specialists, walkable neighborhoods, and the ability to live a full life without always needing a car. The problem is the price of that gift.
CareScout ranked New York near the bottom in 2026, noting that it shares Massachusetts’s extremely high cost of living and has a high personal income tax burden, even though both states offer strong medical environments.
GoBankingRates puts New York’s comfortable retirement cost at $102,674 annually in 2026, making it one of 13 states above the $100,000 mark. For retirees with pensions, paid-off housing, or strong family networks, New York may still make sense. For others, the same state that offers world-class care and culture can drain savings through rent, taxes, utilities, parking, insurance, and basic services.
Some retirees discovered that they loved New York best as a place to visit, not as the place where every doctor visit, grocery trip, and winter heating bill had to fit inside a retirement budget.
Massachusetts
Massachusetts often looks like the sensible choice for retirees who care about hospitals, specialists, education, and proximity to adult children in the Boston orbit. The state’s medical strengths are real, but the affordability problem is real, too.
CareScout ranked Massachusetts 50th in its 2026 retirement list, just ahead of New Jersey, citing the high cost of living and high personal income tax burden despite strong medical environments and doctor availability.
GoBankingRates estimated that a comfortable retirement in Massachusetts costs $136,040 a year in 2026, trailing only Hawaii and California among the states named in its high-cost group. That can create a painful split for retirees: the care may be excellent, the family may be close, and the towns may be charming, but housing, taxes, insurance, heating, and daily expenses can chew through savings.
Some retirees who moved for security later find themselves trading financial ease for medical access. That can still be a wise trade, but it needs to be chosen with clear eyes, not just a hopeful map of grandchildren and hospitals.
Alabama
Alabama can look like a relief valve for retirees fleeing expensive states. Housing can be cheaper, taxes may feel lighter, and GoBankingRates estimated the state’s comfortable retirement cost at $65,797 a year in 2026, far below the high-cost coastal states. But low cost does not answer every retirement question.
CareScout ranked Alabama 48th in 2026, saying the state has low costs but struggles with aging-health indicators, including 71% of Medicare beneficiaries having three or more chronic conditions, plus limited access to arts and recreational centers. Bankrate also placed Alabama among the Sun Belt states that performed poorly in its 2025 retirement ranking.
For some retirees, the regret is not that Alabama is unaffordable. It is that affordability came with tradeoffs they did not weigh hard enough: specialist access, recreation, walkability, social connection, chronic disease support, and day-to-day lifestyle fit. Saving money matters. So does having a life that still feels rich after the boxes are unpacked.
Mississippi
Mississippi shows how complicated retirement rankings can be. Kiplinger named it the most tax-friendly state for retirees in 2026, noting that it does not tax traditional retirement income and has the lowest median property tax bill on its list, at $1,388.
GoBankingRates also placed Mississippi among the states where a comfortable retirement can be achieved with a much lower savings requirement than in high-cost states, with an annual comfortable-cost estimate of $62,623.
But CareScout ranked Mississippi 47th overall for retirees in 2026, citing weak aging-health outcomes, with 67% of Medicare beneficiaries having three or more chronic conditions, and poor access to arts and recreational centers. So the regret risk is clear. Mississippi may be a tax and housing win for some retirees, especially those with family nearby and established care.
But for retirees who need specialist access, active social life, strong senior services, or cultural amenities, the low-cost promise can feel too narrow. Cheap can help the wallet. It does not always help the body or the calendar.
Hawaii
Hawaii is the retirement fantasy that practically writes itself: ocean air, warm weather, lush views, slower mornings, and a sense of escape that can feel almost spiritual. Then the receipt arrives.
GoBankingRates reported in 2026 that Hawaii has the highest annual cost of a comfortable retirement at $181,505, requiring about $5,800 in monthly savings from age 20 through 65, even with Social Security factored in. Its state listing shows a median household income of $100,745 and a 65-plus population share of 20.5%, so it is clearly not empty of retirees.
The problem is the gap between dream and durability. Housing costs, imported goods, interisland travel, mainland family visits, limited options in some health specialties depending on the island, and the price of almost everything can make retirees feel financially boxed in.
Some who moved for beauty later describe a different feeling: being island-locked by cost. For many, regular trips may be cheaper and kinder than full-time paradise.
“Tax Havens”
The last regret category is not a single state but a pattern: chasing tax savings and forgetting the life attached to them. Wyoming, South Dakota, Nevada, Florida, Tennessee, New Hampshire, and similar tax-friendly states can be smart choices for the right retiree, but taxes cannot carry a whole life.
Kiplinger’s 2026 retiree tax guide warns, “no state has zero taxes,” adding that when some taxes are low, other types may be high. CareScout ranked Wyoming No. 1 in 2026 for having no personal income tax, healthier older adults, a moderate cost of living, and a decent average Social Security income, but also noted trade-offs, including weather and the relative scarcity of doctors.
Kiplinger also notes that Wyoming’s remote location can limit access to specialized medical care and that winters are longer and colder than in some states. That is the retirement fine print.
A tax haven may still feel lonely, too rural, too cold, too far from family, too thin on specialists, or too dependent on driving. The smartest move is not the lowest-tax move. It is the one your budget, body, and daily life can keep choosing.
A Short Reflective Close
Retirement regret usually does not stem from a single bad day. It comes from the slow discovery that a place solved one problem and created three others. The state cut taxes but raised insurance. The home was cheap, but the doctor was far away. The beach was beautiful, but the hurricane season felt endless. The mountains were peaceful, but the winter and distance felt isolating.
Bankrate’s 2025 ranking and CareScout’s 2026 ranking both point to the same truth: retirement quality depends on affordability, health care, safety, weather, community, and access, not just one headline perk. The best retirement move is not the one that looks prettiest on a list. It is the one that still fits after the brochure glow fades.
Key Takeaways
Retiree regret often grows in the gap between a state’s headline perk and its lived cost. Florida, Texas, Louisiana, California, and Nevada can attract retirees with sunshine, tax advantages, or lower housing costs in some markets, but insurance, disasters, heat, utilities, and climate risk can quickly change budgets.
The Census Bureau found Florida and Louisiana had the two highest median annual property insurance costs for mortgaged homes in 2023, and the Dallas Fed found Texas home insurance premiums rose 60% from 2019 to 2024.
High-cost states can still offer major benefits, but retirees need to price them honestly. GoBankingRates estimated 2026 comfortable retirement costs of $181,505 in Hawaii, $146,773 in California, $136,040 in Massachusetts, $115,405 in New Jersey, and $102,674 in New York, while CareScout ranked New Jersey, Massachusetts, and New York near the bottom due to high living costs and tax burdens.
Low-cost states are not automatic wins. CareScout ranked Alabama and Mississippi near the bottom in 2026 due to aging-related health outcomes and limited access to arts and recreational centers, even though GoBankingRates shows their annual retirement cost estimates are far lower than those of coastal states.
Tax-friendly states can help, but they cannot replace access to health care, social connection, safe transportation, a comfortable climate, and proximity to loved ones. Kiplinger’s warning that no state has zero taxes is a useful reminder: the right retirement move should pass the whole-life test, not just the tax test.
Disclaimer – This list is solely the author’s opinion based on research and publicly available information. It is not intended to be professional advice.
Like our content? Be sure to follow us
