America’s Economy Still Runs on 12 Broken Models from Its Past

The current battle over Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion (DEI) is a classic economic misdirection. The sitting administration and its critics are locked in a high-stakes cultural war, debating the merits and costs of inclusion, when the truth is that the issues DEI seeks to solve are deeply intersectional with America’s outdated economic structures.

It’s an urgent plea to fix a leak in the attic when the entire basement—the primary models governing healthcare, education, and finance—is flooded. This national focus on changing the “symptoms” is perfectly illustrative. Beneath the surface of today’s heated cultural wars, the American economic engine is still sputtering along on a dozen obsolete frameworks.

These foundational, postwar designs were meant to build one America but are actively creating a fragile, inequitable one today. They are the broken code on which a vast, modern economy runs, and they are warping our markets and draining public wealth.

The Industrial Meat Model

The production of massive quantities of cheap meat is dependent on concentrated animal feeding operations (CAFOs), but this is achieved at a tremendous cost that is not reflected in the price. These industrial operations cause severe environmental damage, including massive water pollution from waste runoff and significant methane emissions, a powerful greenhouse gas.

Furthermore, the crowded conditions and routine use of antibiotics contribute to the serious public health crisis of antibiotic resistance. The price on the sticker is low for consumers. Still, the societal and ecological costs are enormous—an expensive hidden subsidy paid by the planet and the taxpayer through cleanup efforts and rising healthcare expenditures.

The 40-Hour Workweek

The standard 40-hour week, codified in the Fair Labor Standards Act of 1938, was a victory for workers at the time. Yet knowledge work doesn’t track to a factory-floor clock.

Productivity studies have shown that longer schedules reduce hourly efficiency and increase fatigue-related costs. As tasks become more cognitive and less mechanical, the link between time spent and value created continues to weaken. Companies that cling to rigid hour-based systems often see more burnout than output, while those that adapt to flexible, results-oriented structures gain both focus and retention.

The Debt-Financed College Degree

Federal policy, such as significant changes to bankruptcy law, prevents students from discharging most educational debt, meaning the risk rests almost entirely on the individual, not on predatory pricing by institutions.

This has created a generation of graduates whose economic mobility is crippled before they even start, unable to buy homes or invest because they are servicing five- and six-figure debts. The broken model is largely funded by the government guaranteeing the high-cost loans, which removes the incentive for universities to control their costs.

GDP as a National Scorecard

Gross Domestic Product (GDP) measures economic activity but ignores environmental damage, income inequality, and the value of non-market labor (such as child-rearing or volunteer work).

The economist Robert F. Kennedy famously called its limitations out in 1968, saying it “measures everything, in short, except that which makes life worthwhile.” Today, we’re still optimizing for a number that counts the cost of cleaning up an oil spill as a positive economic activity.

Single-Use Zoning

This urban planning model rigorously separates residential areas from commercial and industrial ones, mandating car travel for nearly every chore, from grocery runs to commutes. This segregation principle, common in US city planning since the mid-20th century, not only makes communities less walkable and sociable but is also grossly inefficient due to the massive infrastructure required.

It necessitates continuous investment in costly road expansion and parking structures, which are often subsidized by taxpayers. The model contributes significantly to carbon emissions and high energy consumption by forcing reliance on personal vehicles, ultimately making life more expensive and less convenient for most residents.

The Fee-for-Service Healthcare Pay Model

This system pays doctors and hospitals for the volume of services they perform, not for patient outcomes. It incentivizes more tests, more procedures, and more complex (and expensive) care.

A 2019 JAMA study estimated that the U.S. wastes up to $935 billion a year—nearly a quarter of total healthcare spending—largely because doctors and hospitals are still paid per service rather than by results. This fee-for-service system rewards volume, not value, driving overtreatment, administrative bloat, and inflated prices that inflate GDP without improving health.

Fractional Reserve Banking (The 10% Reserve)

The underlying concept of fractional reserve banking, where financial institutions lend out the vast majority of their deposits while keeping only a small fraction (historically 10% or less) on hand, is inherently unstable. It fundamentally operates as a confidence game; as long as people believe their money is safe, the system works.

However, the 2008 global financial crisis and recent regional bank failures show how quickly a loss of trust can trigger a bank run, causing immediate and systemic collapse. This inherent fragility necessitates massive public bailouts, where taxpayer money is used to rescue private financial institutions to prevent the entire economy from seizing up.

Homeownership as a Pure Investment

Postwar policy engineered the American Dream around a detached, single-family house. This model, supported by zoning restrictions and tax breaks (such as the mortgage interest deduction), turns housing into an asset class for the wealthy and a speculative commodity rather than a place to live. The result? A supply crisis and a cost-of-living disaster for anyone not already on the property ladder.

Postwar suburbia was a carefully constructed social and cultural project, as Ashton Oltmanns explains in his thesis. The design of homes, choice of layouts, and media representation all contributed to a shared national vision of family life and personal success. Magazines and builders worked together to create an idealized suburban experience, which continues to inform American housing aesthetics and cultural values today.

Linear Supply Chains (Just-in-Time)

Global supply chains were meticulously optimized over decades purely for maximum speed and the lowest possible cost, relying on a linear, single-path flow from a single factory abroad to a store shelf here. This minimized storage and carrying costs but eliminated any buffer in the system.

The COVID-19 pandemic and subsequent geopolitical conflicts exposed the profound fragility of this model, demonstrating that when one critical link breaks, everything stops across multiple industries. This immediately led to massive shortages, production halts, and unpredictable price spikes, proving that resilience was fatally sacrificed for efficiency.

Pensions Based on Defined Benefit

This model promised a fixed income in retirement, but it collapsed under a mix of demographic shifts (longer lives) and financial mismanagement. They’ve been largely replaced by the Defined Contribution plan (like the 401k), which shifts all risk and responsibility onto the individual worker, giving them zero guaranteed retirement income.

This substitution effectively turned retirement savings into a high-stakes, individual gamble on the stock market. The ultimate effect is that the average person is now financially unprepared for their later years, a ticking demographic time bomb.

Corporate Shareholder Primacy

The idea that a company’s sole purpose is to maximize short-term profits for its shareholders—popularized by economist Milton Friedman—is a legal and cultural handcuff that has reshaped business priorities. This doctrine mandates that management must prioritize increasing stock price and issuing dividends, often at the expense of other stakeholders, essentially making short-term performance the highest virtue.

It forces executives to prioritize stock buybacks and cost-cutting over essential, long-term investments in research and development (R&D), worker training, or maintaining community stability.

The Federal Tax Code as a Complexity Engine

Instead of a simple, stable way to fund the government’s essential functions, the US tax code is a sprawling, politically motivated mess of loopholes, deductions, and credits that serve specific interests. This complex system of tax expenditures costs billions in lost revenue and administrative overhead for both the government and taxpayers.

The labyrinthine nature of the code primarily benefits those wealthy enough to hire specialized experts and lobbyists to navigate its complexities and find legal ways to minimize their burden. For the average person or small business, it’s a source of stress and inefficiency, leading to countless hours spent on compliance rather than productive work.

Key Takeaways

• Ghost Models: Much of the US economy still relies on frameworks designed for the mid-20th-century industrial era, including concepts like suburbia (Single-Use Zoning) and the fragile JIT supply chain.
• Warped Incentives: Systems like Fee-for-Service Healthcare and the philosophy of Milton Friedman’s Shareholder Primacy create incentives that prioritize short-term profit and volume over long-term stability.
• Hidden Costs: Models like the CAFO industrial meat system and the GDP (as criticized by Robert F. Kennedy) externalize massive costs onto the environment and public health, making the sticker price misleading.

Disclosure line: This article was developed with the assistance of AI and was subsequently reviewed, revised, and approved by our editorial team.

Why investing for retirement is so important for women (and how to do it)

Why investing for retirement is so important for women (and how to do it)

Retirement planning can be challenging, especially for women who face unique obstacles such as the wage gap, caregiving responsibilities, and a longer life expectancy. It’s essential for women to educate themselves on financial literacy and overcome the investing gap to achieve a comfortable and secure retirement. So, let’s talk about why investing for retirement is important for women and how to start on this journey towards financial freedom.

The Billionaire Tax Uproar: 11 Arguments For and Against Wealth Redistribution

The Billionaire Tax Uproar: 11 Arguments For and Against Wealth Redistribution

Wealth redistribution has been a hot-button issue for years, with people on both sides fervently defending their positions. On one side are those who believe that the wealthy should pay more taxes to help fund social programs and support those in need. On the other side are those who argue that taxation is an unfair form of punishment and takes away from individuals’ hard-earned money.