10 hidden American foods that locals keep to themselves

Forget the deep-dish pizza wars and the cheesesteak debates; the real soul of American dining hides in the hyper-local dishes that never quite made it past state lines. I’ve spent years road-tripping through the backroads of this country, and let me tell you, the best stuff isn’t on a billboard, it’s usually wrapped in foil at a gas station or served on a paper plate that threatens to collapse under the weight of grease and glory.

We Americans love our regional secrets. While culinary tourism is exploding, the market is projected to reach $3.7 billion by 2032, according to Fortune Business Insights, yet most travelers still stick to the “greatest hits” menu. But if you want to eat like a true insider (and maybe anger a cardiologist or two), you need to dig deeper. Ready to ruin your diet? Let’s check out the weird, wonderful, and slightly chaotic foods that locals hoard for themselves.

The Rochester garbage plate

If you think the name sounds unappealing, wait until you see it. A “Garbage Plate” is essentially a culinary mosh pit: macaroni salad and home fries (or beans), topped with two cheeseburgers or hot dogs, all buried under a spicy meat sauce, onions, and mustard. I once tried to eat one sober, and I don’t recommend it; this 3,000-calorie beast is designed exclusively for late-night regrets and insulating your body against upstate New York winters.

Legend says Nick Tahou invented this chaotic pile in Rochester, New York, back in 1918 under the name “Hots and Potatoes,” but college students later demanded plates with “all the garbage on it,” and the name stuck. It’s a serious business, too; Nick Tahou Hots actually trademarked the term “Garbage Plate” in 1992 to stop imitators from stealing their thunder.

The West Virginia pepperoni roll

West Virginia miners in the 1920s faced a serious logistical problem: how do you eat lunch underground with one hand covered in coal dust? Giuseppe Argiro, an Italian immigrant baker, solved this in 1927 by baking pepperoni sticks directly inside the dough. The fats from the meat melt into the bread during baking, creating a shelf-stable, no-mess meal that doesn’t require refrigeration.

Locals don’t just eat these; they worship them. Country Club Bakery in Fairmont, the dish’s birthplace, still pumps out between 250 and 900 dozen rolls every single day to keep up with demand. Senator Jay Rockefeller even had to fight the USDA in the 1980s to prevent it from classifying the small bakeries as meat packers, which would have destroyed the industry. Talk about political clout for a snack, right?

The Mississippi slugburger

Relax, it’s not made of slugs. The name comes from the Depression-era slang for a nickel (“slug”), which was the original cost of this burger in 1917. John Weeks brought the concept to Corinth, Mississippi, aiming to stretch beef supplies by mixing the meat with potato flakes or soy grits.

The result is a deep-fried patty that Billy Kramer, founder of NFA Burger, describes as having a “hash brown texture”, crispy on the outside, soft on the inside. You must eat it with mustard, pickles, and onions to cut the grease; cheese is optional but encouraged. It’s so beloved that Corinth hosts a Slugburger Festival every July, drawing thousands of fans to celebrate what is effectively a meat-doughnut.

South Dakota chislic

South Dakota might be the only place in the world where you order “meat cubes” as a standalone meal. Chislic consists of cubed lamb, beef, or venison that locals deep-fry or grill and serve on skewers or with toothpicks, usually accompanied by saltine crackers and garlic salt. It traces its roots to German-Russian immigrants who arrived in the 1870s, adapting the Turkic dish shashlyk to the Great Plains.

This isn’t just a bar snack; it’s the law. In 2018, the state legislature officially declared chislic the “State Nosh” of South Dakota. When the town of Freeman hosted the first South Dakota Chislic Festival that same year, they expected 2,000 people, but 8,000 hungry carnivores showed up, proving that people will travel anywhere for meat on a stick.

The Binghamton spiedie

If you order a sandwich in Binghamton, New York, and it doesn’t take 24 hours to prepare, you’re doing it wrong. A Spiedie (pronounced SPEE-dee) features cubes of chicken, pork, or lamb marinated for at least a full day in a tart “Zuzu” sauce made of vinegar, lemon, mint, and garlic. You grill it, throw it on a slice of soft Italian bread, and eat it without condiments.

Putting ketchup on a Spiedie is practically a crime in Broome County. Locals take this marination magic so seriously that the annual Spiedie Fest and Balloon Rally draws over 100,000 attendees annually. My advice? Don’t ask for the recipe. Families guard their marinade formulas like state secrets, and you honestly don’t want to start a turf war over vinegar ratios.

Cincinnati goetta

Cincinnati has a weird obsession with “grain sausage,” and I am here for it. Goetta (pronounced GET-uh) is a German-American breakfast staple made by mixing ground meat (pork and beef) with steel-cut oats, onions, and spices. It’s fried until crispy, creating a texture that’s crunchy on the outside and creamy on the inside, totally distinct from its mushy cousin, scrapple.

Glier’s, the main producer, cranks out more than 1,000,000 pounds of goetta every year, and amazingly, 99% of it is consumed right there in Greater Cincinnati. It’s such a hyper-local phenomenon that it rarely escapes the city’s gravitational pull. You haven’t lived until you’ve had a “Glier’s Goettafest” weekend, where they serve everything from Goetta nachos to Goetta fried rice.

The St. Louis St. Paul sandwich

This might be the most confusingly named sandwich in history. The St. Paul Sandwich is an egg foo young patty served between white bread with pickles, lettuce, tomato, and mayo. It originated in St. Louis, Missouri, not St. Paul, Minnesota, in the 1940s, likely created by Chinese restaurant owners trying to appeal to American tastes.

It’s an early fusion-cuisine masterpiece that predates the hipster food-truck craze by decades. Chef Ben Welch notes that the sandwich found a loyal following in African American communities, becoming a staple of “Chop Suey” joints across the city. You generally won’t find this anywhere else; try ordering it in actual St. Paul, Minnesota, and the locals will just look at you like you’ve lost your mind.

The Rhode Island hot wiener

Do not, I repeat, do not, call this a hot dog. A Rhode Island Hot Wiener (or “New York System” wiener) is a specific mix of veal and pork, served in a steamed bun and topped with a slow-simmered meat sauce, mustard, onions, and celery salt. The “New York System” name was just a marketing gimmick used by Greek immigrants in the early 1900s to sound fancy.

The service is an art form. Cooks line up a dozen buns along their bare arm (the “up the arm” technique) to dress them at lightning speed. Olneyville New York System, a legendary spot, goes through up to 180 pounds of wieners a day. Locals order them “all the way,” and usually in multiples, because eating just one is physically impossible.

Kentucky burgoo

Think of Burgoo as a “community stew” where the ingredient list is basically “whatever we caught today.” Historically, this thick, spicy stew contained squirrel, opossum, or game birds, though modern versions usually stick to pork, beef, and mutton. It’s a dish meant for crowds, traditionally cooked in massive iron kettles over open fires for political rallies and church picnics.

It is inextricably linked to the Kentucky Derby. The Keeneland Racecourse serves 90-100 gallons of Burgoo every day during race meets. Chef Ouita Michel calls it “a dish that’s filled with so much memory,” noting that you can’t really make Burgoo for one person; it’s food designed to gather a crowd.

The Nebraska Runza

Finally, we have the Runza, a bread pocket stuffed with ground beef, cabbage, and onions that feeds the Cornhusker State. Brought over by German-Russian immigrants (who called them bierocks), these hand-held pies were patented and trademarked by Sally Everett in 1949. The Runza chain now has 85 locations, almost entirely within Nebraska borders.

Is it a sandwich? A pastry? A calzone? Who cares. During Nebraska football games, sales skyrocket because the warm bread doubles as a hand-warmer in the freezing stadium. It’s a brilliant example of functional food. The combination of spiced beef and soft dough beats a standard burger any day of the week.

Key Takeaway

America’s best food isn’t found in Michelin-starred restaurants; it’s hiding in plain sight in neighborhood diners and local bakeries. These 10 dishes, from the calorie-bomb Garbage Plate to the humble Runza, prove that authentic American cuisine is defined by resourcefulness, immigration history, and a healthy disregard for cholesterol. Next time you hit the road, skip the drive-thru and find the weirdest thing on the local menu. Your taste buds (and your Instagram feed) will thank you.

Disclosure: This article was developed with the assistance of AI and was subsequently reviewed, revised, andapproved by our editorial team.

20 Odd American Traditions That Confuse the Rest of the World

20 Odd American Traditions That Confuse the Rest of the World

It’s no surprise that cultures worldwide have their own unique customs and traditions, but some of America’s most beloved habits can seem downright strange to outsiders.

Many American traditions may seem odd or even bizarre to people from other countries. Here are twenty of the strangest American traditions that confuse the rest of the world.

20 of the Worst American Tourist Attractions, Ranked in Order

20 of the Worst American Tourist Attractions, Ranked in Order

If you’ve found yourself here, it’s likely because you’re on a noble quest for the worst of the worst—the crème de la crème of the most underwhelming and downright disappointing tourist traps America offers. Maybe you’re looking to avoid common pitfalls, or perhaps just a connoisseur of the hilariously bad.

Whatever the reason, here is a list that’s sure to entertain, if not educate. Hold onto the hats and explore the ranking, in sequential order, of the 20 worst American tourist attractions.