Fresh vs. Fake: Which Christmas Tree Is Better?

The Christmas season brings a beloved tradition of decorating a tree, and for many, the choice between a fresh tree and an artificial one is a crucial decision. Both types of trees have their unique advantages and disadvantages, ranging from environmental impact to cost and aesthetic appeal. Below, we’ll explore the pros and cons of fresh versus artificial Christmas trees to help you choose the right option for your home this holiday season.

Pros of Fresh Christmas Trees

From fragrance to environmental reasons, let’s look at the positives of fresh, live Christmas trees.

Authentic Holiday Scent and Aesthetic

Fresh Christmas trees bring a natural pine scent that fills the room and creates a nostalgic holiday atmosphere. The scent of a fresh pine or fir tree is often associated with Christmas memories and can enhance the festive feeling. Fresh trees also offer a more organic look, with unique shapes, textures, and colors that artificial trees often try to replicate but can’t entirely match.

Environmental Benefits

Many people assume that cutting down fresh trees harms the environment, but most Christmas trees are grown on sustainable farms. For each tree harvested, farms plant one or more new ones, helping to maintain forested land. Fresh trees are biodegradable and can be recycled through local tree recycling programs, where they are often turned into mulch or compost, benefiting the environment after the holiday season ends. Our neighbors who have goats ask for clean evergreen trees to be dropped off at their farm for their herds.

Supports Local Economy

Purchasing a fresh tree, especially from a local tree farm, supports local agriculture and small businesses. Many family-owned tree farms rely on seasonal sales to stay in business. When you buy a fresh tree, you contribute to local economies, and many tree farms also offer holiday activities like hayrides, which can become part of a family tradition.

Lower Carbon Footprint in Short-Term Use

If you purchase a fresh tree annually, the carbon footprint is relatively low compared to buying an artificial tree, especially if you recycle the tree after use. Artificial trees are typically made from non-renewable plastics and are often imported, increasing their carbon footprint.

Cons of Fresh Christmas Trees

Of course, there are cons as well.

Higher Ongoing Costs

Buying a fresh tree each year can be more expensive over time than purchasing an artificial tree once. The average price of a fresh tree has risen over the years, and depending on the size and variety, a single tree can cost anywhere from $50 to $150 or more. For those who prefer a new tree every season, these expenses can add up significantly over time.

Maintenance and Mess

Fresh trees require consistent maintenance. They need to be watered daily to prevent drying out, which can be an issue if the tree becomes a fire hazard. Fresh trees also shed needles, especially as they dry out, which means more cleaning around the tree. For many, the mess and upkeep can be a hassle, especially with pets or small children in the home.

Limited Lifespan and Disposal

Fresh trees have a limited lifespan and begin to deteriorate shortly after they are brought indoors. Most trees last four to six weeks with proper care, so they are best purchased close to Christmas to avoid early drying. Once the holiday season is over, fresh trees need to be disposed of, which can be inconvenient for those who lack access to a recycling program or need to transport the tree themselves.

Allergen Concerns

Fresh trees can trigger allergies for some people, particularly due to pollen or mold that may accumulate on the tree. Mold spores can increase indoors as the tree sits inside, which can cause issues for individuals with respiratory conditions. For allergy sufferers, artificial trees may be a better choice.

Pros of Artificial Christmas Trees

Many households love their artificial trees.

Long-Term Cost Savings

Although artificial trees come with an upfront cost, they are designed to be reused year after year. High-quality artificial trees can last for a decade or longer, saving you money over time compared to the recurring cost of fresh trees. With a single purchase, you can enjoy your tree each holiday season without the added annual expense.

Convenience and Low Maintenance

Artificial trees are easy to set up and require little to no maintenance. There’s no need to water them, and they don’t shed needles, making them a cleaner option for many households. Additionally, they can be stored after the holiday season and brought out again the following year with minimal hassle, eliminating the need to dispose of a tree each year.

Variety and Customization

Artificial trees come in a wide range of styles, shapes, colors, and sizes. From pre-lit trees to flocked options that mimic a snow-covered look, artificial trees offer customization options that fresh trees simply don’t. Some artificial trees even allow you to change the lighting color or adjust the tree’s height, making it easier to fit into different spaces and decor styles.

Better for Allergies

Artificial trees are generally a better option for households with allergy sufferers. They don’t introduce pollen, mold, or other allergens into the home environment, making them a safer option for those with sensitivities. While dust may accumulate on artificial trees over time, they can be cleaned and maintained more easily than fresh trees.

Cons of Artificial Christmas Trees

What are the negatives associated with artificial Christmas trees?

Environmental Impact

Artificial trees are typically made from non-biodegradable materials, such as PVC plastic, and are often manufactured overseas. These factors contribute to a higher carbon footprint compared to fresh trees. An artificial tree needs to be used for at least 10 years to offset the environmental impact of its production and transportation. Additionally, artificial trees are not recyclable and usually end up in landfills at the end of their life.

Lacks Authentic Scent and Look

Although artificial trees are made to look realistic, they often lack the authentic appearance of a fresh tree. The scent of pine, which many people associate with the Christmas season, is also missing. Some people try to mimic the smell with candles or room sprays, but for many, it’s just not the same as having a real tree.

Storage Requirements

Artificial trees require storage space when not in use. Depending on the size of the tree, it may need a dedicated area in your home, garage, or storage unit. Some people find this inconvenient, especially those living in smaller homes or apartments where storage space is limited.

Higher Upfront Cost

Artificial trees can be expensive, particularly high-quality models that are designed to look like real trees. A good-quality artificial tree can cost several hundred dollars, which may be prohibitive for some families. While the cost is spread out over the years, the initial purchase can still be a significant investment.

Conclusion: Choosing the Right Tree for Your Home

Deciding between a fresh and artificial Christmas tree ultimately depends on your priorities and preferences. If you value the authentic scent and look of a fresh tree and enjoy supporting sustainable farming practices, a fresh tree might be the best choice for you. On the other hand, if you prefer the convenience, cost savings, and low-maintenance nature of an artificial tree, going artificial could be a better fit for your lifestyle.

Both types of trees have pros and cons, and each can add holiday cheer to your home. Whatever your choice, remember that the Christmas tree is a symbol of celebration, family, and tradition—a beautiful reminder of the joy that the holiday season brings.

Banish Holiday Stress with These 18 Do-Ahead Tasks

The holidays are a time for joy, togetherness, and great food. But let’s be honest: they can also be overwhelming. From cleaning and decorating to cooking and hosting, the list of tasks seems endless. Fortunately, a little planning and preparation can make a world of difference. By tackling some tasks ahead of time, you’ll save yourself from last-minute stress and be able to enjoy the festivities with family and friends. Here’s a comprehensive guide to what you can make and do in advance for Thanksgiving and Christmas.

READ: Banish Holiday Stress with These 18 Do-Ahead Tasks

Join Us

Join us on this empowering journey as we explore, celebrate, and elevate “her story.” The Queen Zone is not just a platform; it’s a community where women from all walks of life can come together, share their experiences, and inspire one another. Welcome to a space where the female experience takes center stage. Sign up for our newsletter so you don’t miss a thing, Queen!