The 10 costliest mistakes we make when grocery shopping (and how to fix them)

Americans throw away nearly 40% of their groceries each year, and the way you shop might be part of the problem.

Grocery shopping seems simple—make a list, grab a cart, check out. But those weekly trips to the store are full of sneaky pitfalls that can cost you money, waste food, and sabotage your health goals. Here are 10 of the biggest grocery shopping mistakes people make, and how to avoid them.

1. Shopping Without a List

Wandering the aisles aimlessly is a recipe for impulse buys and forgotten essentials.

Fix It: Before you go, take five minutes to plan meals and write a list. Organize it by category (produce, dairy, pantry, etc.) so you can move through the store efficiently.

2. Going to the Store Hungry

It’s an old cliché for a reason—shopping hungry makes everything look delicious.

Fix It: Eat a snack or meal before hitting the store. Hunger cues increase the likelihood of grabbing chips, candy, or expensive prepared foods you didn’t plan to buy.

3. Falling for Eye-Level Product Placement

Grocery stores strategically place premium (and pricier) items at eye level. Budget or store brands are often shelved high or low.

Fix It: Scan the whole shelf before making a choice. The best deal may literally be right under your nose—or above your head.

4. Ignoring the Unit Price

It’s easy to assume the biggest package is the best value—but not always.

Fix It: Compare the unit price (cost per ounce or gram), listed on the shelf tag. It often reveals that two smaller packages are cheaper than one large one, or vice versa.

5. Forgetting to Check Your Pantry First

How many jars of peanut butter do you really need?

Fix It: Take inventory at home before you shop. A quick pantry and fridge scan can prevent you from overbuying things you already have and letting them expire.

6. Overbuying Perishables

Buying a week’s worth of produce feels virtuous—until half of it goes bad.

Fix It: Be honest about what you’ll actually eat. Stick to produce that can be used in multiple meals, and buy frozen or shelf-stable options as backups.

7. Getting Sucked Into Promotions

Buy-one-get-one offers, and flashy in-store sales can lead to buying things you don’t need or won’t use.

Fix It: Ask yourself: Would I buy this if it weren’t on sale? If not, it’s not a bargain—it’s clutter.

8. Neglecting the Store’s Perimeter

Most whole, minimally processed foods—produce, meat, dairy—are found around the store’s edges.

Fix It: Shop the perimeter first, then dive into the middle aisles only for specific needs like pasta or canned goods. It’s a smart way to prioritize healthier choices.

9. Not Checking Expiration Dates

You might unknowingly grab items close to their sell-by date, which means less time to use them.

Fix It: Always check dates, especially on dairy, meats, and bakery items. Reach toward the back of the shelf if you want the freshest stock.

10. Sticking Rigidly to the Same Store

Loyalty is nice, but it might cost you.

Fix It: Explore other local stores or online grocery platforms. Prices for staples like eggs, cereal, and produce can vary dramatically—even within the same neighborhood. Rotate where you shop, or use apps like Flipp or Basket to compare prices.

The Takeaway

Avoiding these common missteps can save you hundreds of dollars a year, reduce food waste, and help you make smarter choices for your health. Shopping smarter doesn’t take more time—it just takes a little more thought. Next time you grab your keys and a cart, go in with a plan and shop like a pro.

10 Common Online Shopping Habits That Can Get You Hacked

If you buy anything online, even if it’s just once a month, these are the habits that could put you at serious risk. Fix them now before your next checkout.

READ: 10 Common Online Shopping Habits That Can Get You Hacked