The Decline of Google Search and Its Impact on Your Favorite Websites

Google Search, once the gold standard for finding information on the internet, has undergone significant changes over the years. These changes have altered the user experience and profoundly affected content creators and online publishers. Introducing AI-driven features and frequent algorithm updates have led to declining organic search traffic, causing financial strain and uncertainty for many in the digital content industry. Moreover, Google’s practices of scraping and using content created by others without proper compensation have raised serious concerns about copyright infringement and intellectual property theft.

Image credit RYO Alexandre via Shutterstock.

Google’s search algorithm has always been a dynamic entity, evolving to provide users with the most relevant and high-quality results. However, recent updates and the integration of AI technologies have shifted the landscape dramatically.

 Algorithm Updates

Google algorithm.
Image credit azrin_aziri via Shutterstock.

In 2023 alone, Google rolled out several major updates, including core updates in March, August, October, and November, as well as a significant spam update in October. 

Update Effects

frustrated woman on computer.
Image credit pathdoc via Shutterstock.

These updates aimed to enhance search quality by prioritizing high-quality content and reducing spam. However, the frequent changes have led to significant volatility in search rankings, making it challenging for content creators to maintain consistent traffic.

 AI Integration

AI concept.
Image credit Sansoen Saengsakaorat via Shutterstock.

Google’s AI-powered search tool, initially known as the Search Generative Experience (SGE) and now rebranded as AI Overview, has been a game-changer. This tool provides users with summarized answers directly within the search results, reducing the need to click through to publisher websites. 

Does AI Enhance User Experience?

Google AI.
Image credit JRdes via Shutterstock.

While Google claims that this feature enhances user experience, it has led to a substantial decrease in organic search traffic for publishers, with some reporting losses of up to 60%.

The Impact on Content Creators and Publishers

frustrated woman.
Image credit B-D-S Piotr Marcinski via Shutterstock.

The changes in Google’s search algorithms and the introduction of AI-driven features have had dire consequences for content creators and publishers.

 Decline in Organic Traffic

Graph going down.
Image credit Naypong Studio via Shutterstock.

Many publishers have reported significant declines in organic search traffic due to Google’s AI Overviews. For instance, some sites have experienced traffic drops as high as 91%, leading to estimated revenue losses of up to $2 billion. This decline is particularly concerning for independent publishers who rely heavily on search traffic for their revenue.

Financial Strain

upset woman looking at laptop computer.
Image credit Thitiwat Thapanakriengkai via Shutterstock.

The reduction in organic traffic has directly impacted the ad revenue of many publishers. As users find answers directly within Google’s AI summaries, the incentive to visit the original content source diminishes, leading to fewer ad impressions and clicks. 

What Can be Done?

Woman of color deep in thought. Questioning.
Image credit RomarioIen via Shutterstock.

This financial strain has forced some publishers to seek alternative revenue streams or partnerships with other tech companies like OpenAI.

Content Theft and Scraping

woman looking at phone.
Image credit Kiefer Photography via Shutterstock.

Another significant issue is content theft. Scraper bots often steal high-quality content from publishers and republish it on other sites, diluting the original content’s search visibility and harming SEO rankings. Despite Google’s efforts to combat spam and low-quality content, the problem of content theft persists, further exacerbating the challenges faced by content creators.

Google search.
Image credit Wachiwit via Shutterstock.

Google has been accused of scraping content from websites and using it in its AI-generated search results without compensating the original creators. This practice has been likened to copyright infringement and intellectual property theft, as it involves using copyrighted material without permission. 

AI Overview Is A Nightmare

shocked surprised woman on computer.
Image credit fizkes via Shutterstock.

For example, Google’s AI Overview often copies text word-for-word from its training data, which includes content from various websites, and presents it as part of its search results. This not only deprives the original creators of traffic and revenue but also raises legal questions about the fair use of such content.

lawsuit. Gavel. Law.
Legal. Image credit BCFC via Shutterstock.

Several lawsuits have been filed against Google and other tech companies over the unauthorized use of copyrighted content in training AI models. Visual artists, for instance, have sued Google for using their copyrighted images to train its AI-powered image generator, Imagen, without permission. These legal battles highlight the growing tension between content creators and tech giants over the use of copyrighted material in AI technologies.

 The Response from the Industry

woman screaming at laptop. Mad woman.
Image credit Krakenimages.com via Shutterstock.

The response from the content creation and publishing industry has been mixed. Some publishers have opted to collaborate with tech giants, securing licensing deals to monetize their content. Others have taken a more adversarial stance, with lawsuits against companies like OpenAI for using their content without permission.

The Takeaway

Google search.
Image credit PK Studio via Shutterstock.

The evolution of Google Search, driven by frequent algorithm updates and the integration of AI technologies, has significantly impacted content creators and online publishers. The decline in organic search traffic and the financial strain resulting from these changes have forced many in the industry to rethink their strategies and seek alternative revenue sources. Moreover, Google’s practices of scraping and using content created by others without proper compensation have raised serious concerns about copyright infringement and intellectual property theft. As Google continues to refine its search algorithms and AI features, the ability of publishers to adapt and innovate will be crucial for their survival in the digital landscape.

Why Personal Photos On Your Phone Screen Can Pose Security Risks

social media.
Woman using smartphone. Using Image credit Don Pablo via Shutterstock.

We live in a digital age, and while it can offer convenience, we have to be mindful of what we share, for personal security’s sake. Our smartphones, for instance, have become more than just devices; they are extensions of our identities. It’s not uncommon to see individuals customizing their phones with personal photos as wallpapers. While this may seem like a harmless way to express oneself, it can inadvertently expose users to various privacy and security risks. In this article, we explain why setting a personal photo as your phone screen might not be the wisest decision, and we offer alternative solutions to mitigate these risks. READ: Why Personal Photos On Your Phone Screen Can Pose Security Risks

How To Safeguard Your Identity Using RFID Protection

RFID sleeve.
Image credit Jeniffer Fontan via Shutterstock.

We’ve all read those stories or seen the news videos about someone who lost their entire life’s savings because a thief scanned their credit card or bank card that was in their wallet or back pocket. How does this happen and how do you avoid this? Read: How To Safeguard Your Identity Using RFID Protection

Join Us

The Queen Zone Join Us Feature Image
Image Credit The Queen Zone

Join us on this empowering journey as we explore, celebrate, and elevate “her story.” The Queen Zone is not just a platform; it’s a community where women from all walks of life can come together, share their experiences, and inspire one another. Welcome to a space where the female experience takes center stage. Sign up for our newsletter so you don’t miss a thing, Queen!


  • Dede Wilson

    Dédé Wilson is a journalist with over 17 cookbooks to her name and is the co-founder and managing partner of the digital media partnership Shift Works Partners LLC, currently publishing through two online media brands, FODMAP Everyday® and The Queen Zone.

    View all posts

Similar Posts